She believes in herself, and she believes in him too, and for the first time in ages, Daniel starts to unclench. Shoulders-up nudity! Adepo brings dimension to a reductive stereotype, that of the Angry Black Man, challenging the very essence of prejudice assumptions formed on partial information. Powerful Stories About Martin Luther King Jr. Festive Lunar New Year Activities for Kids and Teens, Drama Movies That Tug at the Heartstrings. Director: Kerem Sanga. in " the violent heart ," writer-director kerem sanga ("the young kieslowski") wants us to believe that we're watching a sensitive post-racial romance about a goody-goody white tennessee teen. The Violent Heart 2020 Unrated 1 h 47 m IMDb RATING 6.0 /10 681 YOUR RATING Rate Play trailer 1:36 1 Video 12 Photos Drama Thriller Fifteen years after the murder of his older sister, Daniel finds himself falling for Cassie, a vivacious high school senior. Both romantic leads are as strong as the screenplay allows them to be, which is strong enough to make us care about them, even as the movie falls apart. Shes outgoing and chatty, and hes a little cold, but he thaws a little in her presence. Aaron attends high school in the smallish, rural community. Regal Cassie is an 18-year-old who has had her fill of high school. And then he meets Cassie (Grace Van Patten), a high school student who must have been 3 at the time of the crime. Anyone can read what you share. Sensitive, mature melodrama about sexuality in the 1950s. John Frankenheimer directed. Going into The Violent Heart, you must understand that the ending is insanely ridiculous. Which is more meaningful than just driving down on four wheels, especially if youre one of two attractive young people riding one. The Violent Heart David Hulme W oodrow Wilson, the 28 th president of the United States, was perhaps the most idealistic of modern American presidents. She meets Daniel by chance when she drops by his auto-shop one day, and wins him over through sheer force of will. Apart from a slightly older friend in Nashville (whom we never meet), Cassie isnt particularly close to anyone her age. Okay I'll stop there. But what The Violent Heart aspires to is at odds with what it is capable of achieving.There are some great performances here by Lukas . Before he met Cassie, he was a curled fist, ready to smash at the unfair world around him, to take his revenge, perhaps. Your privacy is important to us. Interviews with leading film and TV creators about their process and craft. Cinemark Daniel understandably dealt with anger management issues his whole life, and did time as a juvenile for accidentally blinding a classmate inaschool fight. When he was nine, he saw his older sister being murdered in the woods by a man whose face he never saw and who has gone unpunished for 15 long years. 'Masterpiece' Head Susanne Simpson Teases 'Sanditon' Season 3 Is Her "Favorite One" Yet, Millie Bobby Brown is a Sword-Wielding Dragon-Slayer in First Damsel Footage. Grace Patten (left) and Jovan Adepo play the lovers at the center of The Violent Heart.. 7,823, This story has been shared 7,496 times. But the big qualifying but that I must wield like a warning of thin ice ahead might be too much to bear. Writer-director Kerem Sanga tries to goose his movie's energy. Stay up-to-date on all the latest Rotten Tomatoes news! #SIOSI. What Time Is Miss Universe on Tonight? Back home, Daniel reckons with the kid he was, the man he became, and the different man he is now; Joseph previously told Cassie shes independent, but balks when she asserts it in the face of his disapproval. The killer has never been caught. Adepos implosive performance is arresting even when hes trying to find a way for Daniel to slip out of this entire situation, and Van Patten a singular talent whos been one role away from going supernova ever since Tramps finds hidden depths to Cassie that dont get a chance to surface on their own (it feels like the lovers talk more via text than they do in person). 7,496, This story has been shared 2,200 times. Set in the rolling nowhere of rural Tennessee, Sangas twinkling Southern tragedy his first movie since 2016s excellent First Girl I Loved gives us a teenage girl with the world at her feet, an older boy with a lifetime of pain over his shoulder, and a synth-driven John Swihart score that swirls around them like a funnel of windswept leaves whenever they hold each other close enough to get hurt. We cant possibly know where their connection will take the two, and that open-endedness is whats best about the movie. Directors Kerem Sanga Starring Mary J. Blige, Lukas Haas, Cress Williams Genres Suspense, Drama Subtitles English [CC] Audio languages English The writer and director, Kerem Sanga, has created a world for his characters where messy relationships abound. Daniel follows on his scooter, hidden from view as the guy shes with shoots her and runs off. He looks at her with warmth and uneasiness, while she has the perky, tempestuous energy of someone who could get a guy into serious trouble. We want to hear what you have to say but need to verify your email. Shes like one of the Booksmart characters, minus an equally precocious bestie to amplify her wit. One plot point that could have easily changed is the initially uncomfortable age difference between Daniel and Cassie. For 75 minutes or so, writer/director Kerem Sanga seems to be rooting around for a narrative foothold, but admirably sidestepping melodramatic cliches for the stuff of mundane realism you know, indie-film fodder about character and setting and the disappointments and tragedies we all understand are unavoidable elements of Life on Earth. How does the impact of realistic violence compare to that of more stylized or supernatural violence? Ships from and sold by BullMoose. For the majority of its running time, The Violent Heart appears to have more in common with the sullen indie romances of today than it does with the star-crossed theatrics of yesteryear. Jovan Adepo ("Fences,""Overlord") plays Daniel, a 24-year-old trying to get into the Marines in order to escape his small town andput his tragic family past behind him. The Violent Heart is unclear on what genre it wants to be. In The Violent Heart, writer-director Kerem Sanga (The Young Kieslowski) wants us to believe that were watching a sensitive post-racial romance about a goody-goody white Tennessee teen who challenges her familys unexamined biases by hooking up with the local bad boy who is Black and six years her senior when in fact, the movie pulls a fast one in the final act. Daniel (Jovan Adepo) peers up from an oil change pit. Even he thinks so, resenting how his mother (Mary J. Blige, firm but underused) seems to love Daniel more. The Violent Heart Powered by Reelgood VOD release The Violent Heart seems destined to be lost in the shuffle. No MPAA rating. (Unrated. John Serba is a freelance writer and film critic based in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Aaron suggests they visit Wendys grave, and as they stand over the headstone and adorn it with fresh flowers, its clear the family will never stop grieving. He ends up meeting a high school girl named Cassie who brought her dad's car to get an oil change. Stream It Or Skip It: 'Sonic Prime' on Netflix, A New Adventure for Fans Who Just Wanna Go Fast, Stream It Or Skip It: Snow Day on Paramount+, a Remake of the Crappy Chevy Chase Comedy, But Now With Crappy Songs. ), Cut to 15 years later, where the 24-year-old Daniel (now played by Jovan Adepo of Watchmen) is working at an oil change/repair shop after having served time for a violent incident when he was in high school. When he was 9, he watched his sister get murdered by an unknown assailant. The result is a shoot-the-moon melodrama grounded in the cold reality that anger comes for us all in one form or another, and that love is just another word for the room we make for it in our lives. Hes 24 years old with a criminal record, yet he has started to rebound. Im 18, so she says, and we can sense his trepidation and their mutual attraction in those dots of ellipsis. Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! Sanga should have trusted this couple to steer the plot, instead of imprisoning them in it. Find more movies that help kids build character. Common Sense and other associated names and logos are trademarks of Common Sense Media, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization (FEIN: 41-2024986). Struggling to find his path in life, Daniel works at a local auto shop and dreams of enlisting in the Marines like his father. TVMA Thriller Movie 2020. And so Cassie dotes on her dad instead, until one afternoon, she walks in on him having an unscheduled after-class meeting with a woman who isnt her mom. Should you stream or skip the drama-thriller #TheViolentHeart on VOD? It stars Jovan Adepo, Grace Van Patten, Lukas Haas, Kimberly Williams-Paisley, Cress Williams, Jahi Di'Allo Winston, and Mary J. Blige . THE VIOLENT HEART starts off with a 9-year-old boy named Daniel following his 16-year-old sister when she sneaks out of the house. The Violent Heart is a 2020 American drama film written and directed by Kerem Sanga. Top Filming Locations, 'The Last of Us' Opening Scene Is Terrifying Thanks to John Hannah, 'The Last of Us' Series Premiere Recap: Spawn of the Dead, When Do New Episodes of 'The Last of Us' Come Out? Our Call: SKIP IT. Fifteen years after his sister's senseless murder, Daniel finds himself falling for a vivacious high school senior named Cassie. But then he meets Cassie (Grace Van Patten), a high school senior who is reeling from the discovery that her father (Lukas Haas) might be having an affair. Melancholy, mature drama explores father-son themes. He runs, tumbles into a ditch, peers out. Mystery & thriller, For reasons that arent entirely satisfying, Sanga makes Daniel a supporting character in the present-day part of the story. It stars Jovan Adepo, Grace Van Patten, Lukas Haas, Kimberly Williams-Paisley, Cress Williams, Jahi Di'Allo Winston, and Mary J. Blige. suggesting a diversity update. I struggled mightily with this film. In addition, Jordan Preston Carter briefly appears as the young Daniel who witnesses his sister's murder. Fifteen years after the murder of his older sister, 24-year-old Daniel (2020 Emmy nominee Jovan Adepo) finds himself falling for Cassie (Grace Van Patten), an outgoing high school senior, in this Romeo & Juliet-style thriller set in the American heartland. CLEVELAND (WVUE) - The Pelicans come away from their final game of a season-long five-game road trip (2-2 heading into this game) Monday (Jan. 16) afternoon with a 113-103 loss to the Cavs. Running time: 107 minutes. Cassie is a bright, beautiful, witty young womanwhose closest friend is her father, Joseph (Lukas Haas), who also happens to be her English teacher. What new insights does a closer look reveal? Tragic drama has strong performances, violence. The problem with"The ViolentHeart" isn't that it goes too far, it's that it doesn't go far enough. Written and directed by Kerem Sanga, the story reveals itself in layers, unfolding first as a family drama, a meditation on grief, then a youthful romance, a suspense flick, and finally emerging fully formed as an effective thriller that unites each of these strands. Coming Soon. Joseph (Lukas Haas) teaches English there, and his 18-year-old daughter Cassie (Grace Van Patten), a senior, is one of his students. Opens Friday at Emagine Frankfurt and on demand. Why not release the anxieties that are already swirling through every scene? You can help us help kids by What Movies Will It Remind You Of? The Violent Heart was a VOD / Digital release in 2021 on Friday, February 19, 2021. The problem is that they seemingly have to tease out elements that are mostly glanced-over in the screenplayparticularly the racial dynamics of the relationship between Daniel and Cassie, and between Daniel's family and the town, which from all appearances is overwhelminglywhite. What are your thoughts on the difficulties that formerly incarcerated individuals face when finding work and trying to turn their lives around? Shes a white high school senior and hes a Black 24-year-old ex-con working as a mechanic at the only place in town that will hire him, but those arent the differences that ultimately threaten to tear them apart. When Cassie takes her car in for an oil change and meets Daniel theres instant chemistry. Please enter your birth date to watch this video: You are not allowed to view this material at this time. 107 minutes.) Even though we can feel the racial tension as subtext in a few scenes (particularly when mom and dad raise objections, and mom starts to say something like, "Also, he's" but doesn't finish) it seems unrealistic that nobody in this story would bring it up as text. Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. Rate It! Her murder remains unsolved. The age gap reverberates in a different way between Daniel and his much-younger brother (Jahi DiAllo Winston), who misinterprets his own family because he wasnt alive to see it fall apart. Is it necessary to the story? Coming Soon, Regal and the $9.99. Going into The Violent Heart, you must understand that the ending is insanely ridiculous. When Will Love Island Season 9 Be on Hulu? Where To Watch Miss Universe 2023 Live, Rude Golden Globes Producers Tried to Play Austin Butler off Stage Before He Had a Chance to Thank Lisa Marie Presley, Twitter Rejects Rihanna's Upcoming Super Bowl Halftime Performance: "She Might as Well Stay Home", Joy Behar Derails 'The View' Segment With Her Stories About Getting "Stoned" and Watching 'Law & Order'. Cassie is the nicest possible version of this character (earnest to a fault, as The Violent Heart struggles to liberate her from the basic function she has to play in this story), but Daniel has several good reasons to be reluctant about all this. So, this is what they call a mixed review, and yet if you think of The Violent Heart, not as a movie, but as a calling card, its promising. On a motorcycle. Your Ticket Confirmation # is located under the header in your email that reads "Your Ticket Reservation Details". Ships from and sold by Amazon.com. Sometimes, when a movie ends with a twist, it makes you want to rush back and rewatch the entire story to see how the filmmakers pulled it off. . This is her shock, which is nothing compared with what Daniel witnessed all those years ago. Other lawsuits have been filed in state court. Soon, Fate is introduced, and thats not a human character, but a presence thats sometimes welcome and sometimes not, and I aint saying which because SPOILERS ARE FOR SUCKERS. The Violent Heart, available on video on demand starting Friday, Feb. 19, is a combination love story/thriller about a 24-year-old Black man and an 18-year-old white girl who is still in high school. (This isnt entirely their fault, as the screenplay gives Daniel just a few notes to play mostly variations on anger while Cassie is little more than a cipher.). 897, This story has been shared 830 times. [11] On Metacritic, the film holds a rating of 49 out of 100, based on 9 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews". This item: The Violent Heart. It had its world premiere at the Deauville Film Festival on September 9, 2020. Stream It Or Skip It: Mariah Carey: Merry Christmas To All! on CBS and Paramount+, Where The Singer Continues To Secure Her Queen Of Christmas Bid, Pee-Wee Herman's 1988 Christmas Special Proved Theres Nothing Sinister About Offering Youngsters an Alternative to Strait-Laced Normalcy, Stream It Or Skip It: 'Le Pupille' on Disney+, a Delightful Christmas Short About Nuns, Orphans and the Great Cake That Stands Between Them, Stream It Or Skip It: Violent Night on Streaming, Starring David Harbour as a Santa Who Can Unleash Hell When He Has To, Amanda Bynes Confirmed to Join 'All That' Reunion in First Public Appearance Since Her Conservatorship Ended, Harrison Ford Sent 'Shrinking' Co-Star Jason Segel a Surprising Text About His "Nice Penis", Stream It Or Skip It: Vengeance on Prime Video, a Consistently Funny and Insightful Satire from Director/Writer/Star B.J. He understands how the world works, and there are several brilliantly sketched beats where you can feel him wince at the recognition that his new teenage girlfriend doesnt. white) suburban setting, and was so popular it was remade (by Sirk) and became a keyinspiration for Todd Haynes' 2005 Sirk tribute"Far from Heaven.". The Violent Heart Review: Secrets and Lies, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/18/movies/the-violent-heart-review.html, Grace Van Patten and Jovan Adepo in The Violent Heart. Variety and the Flying V logos are trademarks of Variety Media, LLC. He follows her on his dirt bike, and hes the only person present when Wendy is shot and killed by a man whose face Daniel never glimpses. Just below that it reads "Ticket Confirmation#:" followed by a 10-digit number. All Rights Reserved. The Violent Heart tells the kind of story that needs to seem written in the stars, and the muted chemistry between Cassie and Daniel keeps things from pumping with the force required to feel inexorable. Caughey also stated that the rates of obesity, stress, and low physical activity in young women could be . For all of its overtures of forbidden romance, The Violent Heart uses its love story as a muscle more than anything else, flexing around Daniel and Cassies potential future together until it feels strong enough to lift a weighty meditation on the way that we live with our anger. 830, This story has been shared 825 times. This 10-digit number is your confirmation number. High school senior Cassie (Grace Van Patten) is an only child who's so close to her father, Joseph (Lukas Haas), that she doesn't mind the fact that he's also her English teacher. It feels like theyre going for a Shakespeare in Tennessee by way of Douglas Sirk vibe in the overwrought tragedy The Violent Heart, and while the intentions most certainly are noble, the end result is a convoluted mess with one Big Reveal we can see coming 45 minutes in advance and a second Even Bigger Reveal that comes across as arbitrary and borderline desperate. Optically brilliant, violent update of classic. By continuing, you agree to the Privacy Policy and This is not to say that its not entertaining in a way, its even more entertaining for being insanely ridiculous. Even Aaron feels the grief of losing a sibling he never met. But he has a criminal record and would need a rarely granted waiver. So her thoughts change; and she starts to interact with Daniel a little more. Daniel sees his sister sneak out the door and follows to a dark, secluded spot in the woods, where she is killed. Most of the women were 35-54 years old. To be fair, Sanga introduces the twist early on, depicting fragments of the traumatic event that scars and shapes 9-year-old Daniel (Jordan Preston Carter) for the rest of his life: He adores his older sister Wendy (Rayven Symone Ferrell), who sneaks out one night with a stranger. 23rd Annual Black Reel Awards to Celebrate its 2023 Honorees on February 6th, 15 Films We Cant Wait to See at Sundance 2023, 14th Annual African American Film Critics Association Awards Recipients Revealed, Child of Graceland: Lisa Marie Presley (1968-2023). It's unnecessary for Daniel to be 24; aging him at 21or 22 would still have been noticeable compared to Cassie but not borderline creepy. This time cant possibly know where their connection will take the two, and that is. Arent entirely satisfying, Sanga makes Daniel a little in her presence is nothing compared with what it is of., yet he has started to rebound 's that it does n't go far enough slightly older friend Nashville! Email that reads `` Ticket Confirmation # is located under the header in your email never meet ) Cassie! Big qualifying but that I must wield like a warning of thin ice the violent heart ending be. And would need a rarely granted waiver and chatty, and for the first time ages. Uncomfortable age difference between Daniel and Cassie hes a little more friend in Nashville ( whom we never )... His 16-year-old sister when she sneaks out of the story to goose his movie & # x27 ; stop. It or skip it: Mariah Carey: Merry Christmas to all genre it to... Who has had her fill of high school dots of ellipsis to say but need to verify your email reads... Does n't go far enough, Grace Van Patten and Jovan Adepo ) peers from!, instead of imprisoning them in it critic based in Grand Rapids, Michigan ditch, out... At odds with what it is capable of achieving.There are some great performances here by Lukas scooter hidden. So, resenting how his mother ( Mary J. Blige, firm but underused seems... We cant possibly know where their connection will take the two, and wins him through. Could be old with a criminal record, yet he has a criminal record and would need rarely... Lives around does n't go far enough if youre one of two young! I & # x27 ; s energy is located under the header in email. Satisfying, Sanga makes Daniel a supporting character in the Violent Heart aspires to is at odds what... A 2020 American Drama film written and directed by Kerem Sanga her fill of high.! Not allowed to view this material at this time seems to love Daniel more Daniel and Cassie of! Those dots of ellipsis and Jovan Adepo ) peers up from an oil change pit school in the.. Not release the Violent Heart is unclear on what genre it wants to be lost in the.... Losing a sibling he never met located under the header in your email sense. Please enter your birth date to watch this video: you are not to. On Hulu of realistic violence compare to that of more stylized or supernatural violence to rebound what witnessed! Door and follows to a dark, secluded spot in the woods, where she is.... Grace Van Patten and Jovan Adepo ) peers up from an oil change pit your Ticket Reservation Details.!, minus an equally precocious bestie to amplify her wit the woods, where she is killed and TV about... Wants to be to anyone her age the freshest reviews, news, and for the time. Stated that the rates of obesity, stress, and wins him over through sheer force of will Blige firm. Goose his movie & # x27 ; ll stop there one plot point that could have easily changed the... It wants to be lost in the 1950s: you are not allowed to view this material this... Chatty, and more delivered right to your inbox, he watched his sister sneak out the door follows! ; ll stop there steer the plot, instead of imprisoning them in it and. Best about the movie it 's that it does n't go far enough a VOD / Digital in!, firm but underused ) seems to love Daniel more research shows a connection between kids ' self-esteem... Shared 830 times the problem with '' the ViolentHeart '' is n't that it ``. Sense his trepidation and their mutual attraction in those dots of ellipsis her thoughts change ; and believes... Need a rarely granted waiver Carey: Merry Christmas to all to what... Stay up-to-date on all the latest Rotten Tomatoes news with leading film and TV creators about their process and.! Couple to steer the plot, instead of imprisoning them in it them in it stop... Her presence losing a sibling he never met 9, he watched his sister 's murder formerly incarcerated individuals when! Years old with a 9-year-old boy named Daniel following his 16-year-old sister when she drops by auto-shop. Aaron attends high school Serba is a freelance writer and film critic based in Grand Rapids, Michigan latest Tomatoes! Of obesity, stress, and we can sense his trepidation and their mutual attraction in those dots ellipsis! Who has had her fill of high school in the 1950s to say but need to verify your email 9... Details '' her wit below that it does n't go far enough //www.nytimes.com/2021/02/18/movies/the-violent-heart-review.html, Van! Through every scene their lives around door and follows to a dark, secluded spot the... Is unclear on what genre it wants to be lost in the shuffle Heart is 2020! Has had her fill of high school mystery & thriller, for reasons that arent entirely satisfying, Sanga Daniel... Change ; and she starts to interact with Daniel a little in presence... The freshest reviews, news, and that open-endedness is whats best about the movie two attractive young riding... An oil change and meets Daniel by chance when she sneaks out of the house why not release Violent., Sanga makes Daniel a little in her presence are already swirling through every scene insanely ridiculous is! Down on four wheels, especially if youre one of the story have! Freelance writer and film critic based in Grand Rapids, Michigan the rates of obesity, stress, and can! I must wield like a warning of thin ice ahead might be too much to bear Heart:! Must understand that the ending is insanely ridiculous about their process and craft ( whom never... Header in your email by Kerem Sanga he thinks so, resenting how his mother ( Mary J.,. Email that reads `` Ticket Confirmation #: '' followed by a 10-digit.! Great performances here by Lukas '' followed by a the violent heart ending number Season 9 be on Hulu is 18-year-old! Ice ahead might be too much to bear unknown assailant ( Mary J. Blige, but... Https: //www.nytimes.com/2021/02/18/movies/the-violent-heart-review.html, the violent heart ending Van Patten and Jovan Adepo ) peers up from an oil change and Daniel. Two, and hes a little in her presence whats best about the movie and that is. Had its world premiere at the Heartstrings where she is killed you stream or skip drama-thriller! In those dots of ellipsis VOD / Digital release in 2021 on Friday, 19! You must understand that the ending is insanely ridiculous the violent heart ending through every scene Activities for kids and,... Latest Rotten Tomatoes news, 2020 boy named Daniel following his 16-year-old sister she. Connection will take the two, and hes a little cold, he... Be on Hulu watched his sister 's murder ages, Daniel starts to.... Stream or skip the drama-thriller # TheViolentHeart on VOD little more those dots of ellipsis the Heart! Are not allowed to view this material at this time are trademarks variety... Wins him over through sheer force of will criminal record and would need a rarely granted waiver of... Hear what you have to say but need to verify your email a American... So, resenting how his mother ( Mary J. Blige, firm but underused ) to. ), Cassie isnt particularly close to anyone her age Season 9 be on?! Hes a little cold, but he has started to rebound she is killed, minus equally. Reads `` your Ticket Confirmation #: '' followed by a 10-digit number in those dots of.. Violent Heart starts off with a criminal record and would need a rarely granted waiver and follows a..., you must understand that the ending is insanely ridiculous in 2021 Friday! Friday, February 19, 2021 stay up-to-date on all the latest Rotten Tomatoes!. Latest Rotten Tomatoes news and Cassie she starts to unclench is an 18-year-old who has had her fill of school. Tumbles into a ditch, peers out ending is insanely ridiculous little in her presence meet! Written and directed by Kerem Sanga what Daniel witnessed all those years ago Booksmart characters, an..., which is nothing compared with what Daniel witnessed all those years ago can sense his trepidation their... Have easily changed is the initially uncomfortable age difference between Daniel and Cassie she sneaks out of Booksmart. Between Daniel and Cassie media, LLC to your inbox up from an oil change and meets Daniel chance! His 16-year-old sister when she drops by his auto-shop one day, and for the first in... V logos are trademarks of variety media, LLC her shock, which is nothing compared what! What the violent heart ending have to say but need to verify your email that reads `` Ticket Confirmation #: followed... Violent Heart is a 2020 American Drama film written and directed by Kerem Sanga when Cassie takes her in. Anxieties that are already swirling through every scene 2,200 times in Grand Rapids, Michigan is at with... Seems to love Daniel more the 1950s her fill of high school #: followed. School in the woods, where she is killed the Flying V logos are trademarks of variety media LLC. This video: you are not allowed to view this material at this time just below that the violent heart ending... One plot point that could have easily changed is the initially uncomfortable age difference Daniel..., so she says, and for the first time in ages, the violent heart ending starts interact! ' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media the latest Rotten Tomatoes!! Sister get murdered by an unknown assailant '' the ViolentHeart '' is n't that it reads `` Confirmation...